• Who Should I Vote For? #2

    Posted on October 8, 2015 by in MARK'S REMARKS, Politics

    If you’ve looked at my Fair Voting page you will know that I support proportional representation (PR) as a better way to elect MPs (or MLAs or municipal councillors) than our present pluralitarian system, more commonly known as Winner Take All (WTA) or First-Past-the-Post (FPTP). That sort of system produces distorted results. In the 41st Canadian General Election in 2011 where only 61% of the electorate voted, 39% voted Conservative and won 54% of the seats in Parliament. When you have 54% of the seats, you have an absolute majority so 100% of the power. Sixty-one percent of the votes cast, including many Conservative votes, were wasted and served to elect no-one. Put another way, 23% of the electorate gave the government 100% of the power.

    The Alberta general election produced a similar result in May 2015. Albertans voted 40.6% for the NDP which won 61% of the seats in the legislature and 100% of the power. Only 54.2% of electors actually voted, so 22% of the electorate gave the government 100% of the power.

    With results like those, it is hardly surprising that people grumble, starting immediately after the results are announced.

    Fair Vote Canada and Fair Vote Calgary have been trying to find out where parties and candidates stand on PR. The results are encouraging, and in keeping with the polls that have been conducted over the last few years – about 70% of Canadians want to see PR introduced to replace our WTA system, and many candidates support electoral reform and possibly the introduction of PR.

    This graphic shows where the parties stand (click to enlarge):


    Fair Vote Canada has developed a Canada-wide listing of candidates who have responded to a questionnaire about PR and you can find it here.

    Fair Vote Calgary has done a similar exercise focussing on candidates in southern Alberta. You can see here which candidates and parties have declared support for PR.

    There are further details of all local candidates (where their position is known) in a table which you can download here.

    So, in answer to my question ‘Who should I vote for’ my reasoning works like this:

    •    In my opinion, the greatest threat we have in Canada is not jobs, security, economy, hijabs, or taxes. Democracy itself is under threat from our politicians, who since the 1970s have progressively been taking more and more power from the people and adding it to the government, particularly recently to the unelected and not-answerable-to-Parliament Prime Minister’s Office.

    •    The first step to correct this issue is to elect MPs in such a way that every vote counts toward electing an MP, so that membership of the House of Commons reflects the popular vote. In the future, decisions by Parliament should reflect the wishes of the electorate (but there’s much more work to do to achieve that goal).

    •    In this election, each of us should vote for a candidate who if (no, when) elected will work to introduce PR. A majority of MPs (170) could ensure PR is introduced by the next scheduled general election in 2019.

    •    Check out the information referenced above and make your candidate choice, or perhaps select alternative candidates you might vote for.

    •    In some electoral districts, it may be preferable to vote for a candidate who is likely to win if he or she attracts enough votes and who supports PR but is not necessarily your first choice. Personally, I don’t like or believe in strategic voting (see my previous post).

    Most important of all – Just Vote! Don’t be among the 40% of the electorate that stays away from the ballot box. By now you should  have received a Voter’s Card with the information you need. If you haven’t, contact your local Elections Canada office as soon as possible. You can find it’s address on their web site.

    There’s little to no excuse not to vote – you can go now to the Elections Canada office in your electoral district (the address is on your voter’s card). You can go to an advance poll (the days, place and opening times are on your voter’s card). You can even go to your polling station on Election Day, Monday 19 October if you enjoy standing in line (the address is on your voter’s card – but also check Elections Canada’s web site).

Comments are closed.